Landscapes Of The Mind
  • Home
  • Musings & Reflections
  • Glimpses Through The Lens
    • The Feathered Beauties
    • I Saw,I Clicked... >
      • Vishnupur
      • The Tantalizing Landscape Of Uttaranchal
      • Amidst The Sand Dunes Of Khuri
      • Chatris Of Shekawati
      • Havelis Of Shekawat
    • I Saw, I Clicked Part II >
      • Hosaholalu
      • Pristine Havelock
      • Pichavaram
      • Chidambaram
    • I Saw I Clicked Part III >
      • Yosemite
      • A Day At The Vatican Museum
      • Norcia
      • Moscow
    • Butterflies & Flowers
    • Close Encounters At Corbett
    • Bijapur & Beyond
    • Enchanting Athirapalli
    • Splendours of Seatlle
    • Monet's Garden
  • Glimpses Through The Lens: II
    • Poetry in stone >
      • Brihadeeswarar Koil
      • Gangaikondacholapuram
      • Dharasuram
      • Thanjavur Art Gallery
    • In The Land Of Enlightenment
    • Charming Chitrapu
    • Exploring Orissa >
      • Mesmerizing Mangalajodi
      • Bewitching Bhetnoi
      • Daksa Prajapati Temple
    • Birding Down Under >
      • Parrots Galore!
      • Lyrical Lyre Bird
      • Honey Eaters
      • Kingfishers, Wrens, Wagtails, Warblers...
      • Orioles, Golden Whistlers
      • Cockatoos, Kookaburras & Magpies
      • Pigeons, Doves
      • Birds Of Prey, Bower Birds
      • Water Birds & In Flight
      • Others
    • Murals of Pundarikapuram
  • Contact Me

A Perspicacious Bird!

9/20/2019

29 Comments

 
​
It is hard to miss the California Scrub Jay.

As I watch it alight on a branch, it announces its presence with a loud, raucous squawk. Emily Dickinson called them “blue terriers” for their bark- like call. Not quite on par with other songbirds!
​
It was hopping in bold lunges, pumping its tail and looking around with quick twists of the head. Charging through the branches as if sprinting down a path, it scared other birds away with an aggressive and purposeful energy.

The California Scrub Jay compensates it’s belligerent stance and lack of melodious call with a striking appearance. They are handsome birds with azure blue wings, tail and head, with light gray underparts and a distinctive white throat and eyebrow. Its feathers are not actually blue!  The bright sapphire color we see is in fact, the result of the unique inner structure of the feathers, which distorts the reflection of light off the bird, making it appear blue.  If that structure were to be damaged by crushing the feathers, the blue color would go away. The pigment in their feathers is melanin, which is brown. The blue color is caused by light dispersed through modified cells on the surface of the feather barbs.

One of the important characteristics of the California Scrub Jay is their “caching behavior”. As scrub jays spend their day foraging for seeds and acorns, they hoard their stash in little piles all over their territory in order to ensure supplies when food is scarce. Rather than building up one big pile, jays hide their bounty in many smaller piles. This strategy is called “scatter-hoarding” and leads to jays amassing up to 200 caches within their home ranges, which average about 1/10 of a square mile.  Scrub jays must have excellent spatial memories just to remember where they have stockpiled all these future snacks. This is a rather impressive task. I wonder whether anyone can remember the last 200 places they ate at?!  Since the hippocampus is the part of the brain that is involved in memory formation and storage, researchers have speculated if scrub jays have particularly large hippocampi, given all this remembering that they must do. Turns out that scrub jays do have one of the largest hippocampus sizes compared to their body size. The important factor is not absolute brain size but brain size relative to body weight, often termed as the “encephalization quotient.”

The size of the hippocampus also comes in handy when the California Scrub Jay wants to plan ahead. This is important because they store not only nuts and seeds but fruit, insects and worms, foods that perish at different rates. Cached insects can spoil in days if the temperatures are high enough, while nuts and seeds can last for months. A series of creative experiments by Nicola Clayton and her team at Cambridge University showed that the birds retrieve the more perishable food before it rots, leaving the nonperishables, such as nuts and seeds, until later. The jays use their experience of how quickly food degrades to guide their choice in recovering their caches. Remembering that perishable food items may need to be retrieved sooner requires recalling cache locations, cache contents, and the time of caching. This ability to remember the what, where, and when of specific past events is thought to be akin to human episodic memory, the remarkable capacity to remember specific personal experiences. Like us, the birds seem to be using events that happened in the past (what they buried when) to figure out what to do now or in the future (dig up or save until later).

Besides their remarkable memory, scrub jays also seem to have a social awareness that they employ for more deceptive purposes. Scrub jays often cache in a secretive manner to protect their stores from other birds, hiding behind objects, or relying on shade to obscure them from other birds’ view.  Sometimes though, these efforts are not enough. If jays “believe” another bird is watching them cache, they will return to the cache later and “re-cache” it to a new secret location so that their food cannot be stolen. To do this, the jays must be able to “understand” in some way that the other birds are not only able to see what they are doing but also use that information to preserve their hard-earned seeds. This requires a social skill called ‘theory of mind’. Theory of mind involves the ability to understand what other individuals know. Simply put, it is the ability to realize that another bird is watching its cache with an intent to steal it, and that hiding that snack in a new location could trick the other and protect the food. The capacity to take the perspective of the other and to grasp what might be going on in another creature’s mind is one of the hallmarks of theory of mind.

Theory of mind may sound basic, but it is a demanding and complex social ability that even humans struggle with. A human infant may not develop theory of mind until around four years of age. Hence, claiming jays have this ability has literally ruffled feathers among biologists and psychologists alike. Some have suggested that this might just be an example of social learning, when birds find from trial and error that not moving your food can lead to unfortunate consequences.

Yet another astonishing fact about this Machiavellian tactical caching behavior is that a California Scrub Jay will resort to these clever tactics, only if it had its own experience in stealing from others. Birds that have never pilfered themselves hardly ever recache. In other words, “it takes a thief to know a thief!”

Scrub jays are also among the most social of birds. They participate in cooperative breeding, when they share the responsibility of raising the young. These brainy birds also watch out for each other while foraging and feeding in groups. They post a sentinel, or lookout, and take turns watching for predators, enabling the other members of the flock to forage with greater concentration and less danger of being captured by a predator.

There has been a lingering question as to whether birds experience human social or emotional capacities such as grief. For example, it has been observed that once the California Scrub Jays spot a dead member of their flock, they make loud alarm calls to draw the attention of others. The other jays then stop foraging and congregate near the dead bird and some remain close to the dead bird even for a day or two. Were they mourning a fallen member of the jay tribe? Or were they just demonstrating how birds respond to a dead member of their own species, by noisily telling other birds about the death and perhaps alerting the group to danger, a behavior that is often termed as “cacophonous aggregation”.

It is imperative that we are cautious while imputing human emotions like grief to other species. It is very easy to slip into the anthropomorphic trap!

But what is so remarkable is that the California Scrub Jays are capable of some form of metacognition. Many such abilities and skills have been outlined by Jennifer Ackerman in her masterly tome, Genius of Birds.

Thus, to call someone “bird-brained” is inaccurate and an unfortunate insult to the avian species!

On an altogether different note, it seems timely to recall the classical song, Bird Brain by the inimitable Alan Ginsberg. It is a six and half minute song recorded with a Denver based group called The Guons. It starts with these scathing lines;
 “Birdbrain runs the world
 Birdbrain is the ultimate product of Capitalism
…”

Not too inappropriate in these times….

PS:
​You might wonder why I called this bird perspicacious and not just brainy. Perspicacious is somewhat similar to being shrewd or astute. But there is a subtle difference. All three mean acute in perception and sound in judgment, but ‘shrewd’ stresses practical, hardheaded cleverness, whereas ‘perspicacious’ implies unusual power to see through and comprehend what is puzzling or hidden. And ‘astute’ suggests both shrewdness and perspicacity combined with diplomatic skill. The ability to quickly pick out from among the many things, those that are significant and to synthesize these observations and develop a practical strategy is what is characteristic of being perspicacious and the California Scrub Jay symbolizes it. 

A skill that many a psychotherapist will be envious of!


GLIMPSES OF THE CALIFORNIA SCRUB JAYS AT: 
photos.app.goo.gl/YSD1BrtiBEFmp7GL7

KINDLY POST YOUR COMMENTS HERE AND NOT IN GOOGLE PHOTOS!
29 Comments
Dr.priya
9/21/2019 06:07:36 pm

Very informative & interesting doctor ..very well written also
Dr.priya

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/21/2019 08:37:49 pm

Thank you Dr Priya

Reply
Naveen Chandar
9/21/2019 06:29:50 pm

Dear Dr, your "perspicuous"writing on the California Scrub Jay's "perspicacious" abilities, is well worth the bird's envy inducing brain.you write well on Nature. Blessings.

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/21/2019 08:38:12 pm

Thanks Naveen!

Reply
Ajit Bhide
9/21/2019 06:31:47 pm

Wonderful. Will now use 'bird-brain' only as a compliment.

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/21/2019 08:38:35 pm

Ha ha!

Reply
Ramesh Santhanam
9/21/2019 06:32:46 pm

Very much like our Indian roller. Not sure whether they have the same capacity, and habit, to 'scatter-hoard'. Cheers

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/21/2019 08:39:03 pm

I wonder!

Reply
Preethi Krishnan
9/21/2019 09:41:57 pm

Enjoyed reading Dr R...thank you very much for all your creative teaching.
Preethi

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/21/2019 10:37:29 pm

Thanks Preethi!

Reply
Arun Kishore
9/21/2019 10:45:40 pm

Astute observations and writing. Thanks to your write up, I will now look out for other bird brains. Certainly look up the Alan Ginsberg song and Ackerman's book .

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/22/2019 08:48:03 am

Thanks!
Ackerman's book is a fantastic read Arun!

Reply
Sadasivan Jagdish
9/21/2019 11:30:05 pm

A good read.D
not know anything about this bird.
My favourite bird is the crow !

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/22/2019 08:48:29 am

Crows are as intelligent!

Reply
Ravi M
9/21/2019 11:35:58 pm

Interesting
Now I know why prabha thinks IAM. A bird brain !

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/22/2019 08:49:20 am

Are you sure that she was calling the right brain:-)

Reply
S R Jayaprakash
9/22/2019 12:51:47 am

Thought of writing something smart, in reply. Not much occurred to my bird brain. Now, now I can't even say that!!
Beautifully rendered, Raghu, as always.

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/22/2019 08:50:11 am

Thanks SR.

Reply
Shaji KS
9/22/2019 05:25:15 am

Very interesting observations and interpretations. Love the clarity of expression. Well written Ragu

Reply
Prof Raguram
9/22/2019 08:50:23 am

Thanks Shaji!

Reply
Shabbir Amanullah
9/24/2019 06:45:25 am

Sublime!

Reply
Dr Raguram
10/2/2019 11:06:38 am

Thanks Shabbir!

Reply
Ajay
9/25/2019 11:53:47 pm

I do envy the Californian Scrub Jay's perspicacity! Here in Melbourne the Australian magpie is everywhere and it is also said to be very clever but have not read anything this amazing about it. It's vocal skills are quite something though.

Reply
Dr Raguram
10/2/2019 11:08:57 am

Australian magpies living in large families are reportedly more intelligent!

Reply
Joy
9/27/2019 12:41:03 am

Dr. These are amazing pics

Reply
Dr Raguram
10/2/2019 11:09:12 am

Thanks Joy!

Reply
Bhavani Hamann
10/1/2019 06:53:06 pm

A quality I yearn to possess!! Percipience in writing and collecting your concepts- it’s amazing! I’ve seen jays spread their brilliant wings in flight and never knew the humble brown had its glory in the sunlight playing on the unique wing structure ! Sagacity is another word that comes to mind but unlike you my words stay as simple words, while you paint such vivid vistas! Thanks so much!

Reply
Dr Raguram
10/2/2019 11:10:24 am

Thanks Bhavani! Tucked in their iridescent feathers is a remarkable talent!

Reply
Manju
11/30/2019 06:34:17 pm

Such a wonderful, humbling read Sir! These mighty minds always amaze me..... I wonder if neocortex is really all that is made out to be, when nature seems so efficient with these birds. Even with the absence of "prefrontal cortex," birds exhibit more purposeful behavior than a sapien with a sizeable neocortex! Indeed they are perspicacious! Thanks for a meaningful lesson!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Dr Raguram

    Someone who keeps exploring beyond the boundaries of everyday life to savor and share those unforgettable moments....

    Archives

    October 2022
    September 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    May 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly